Naturally, I went into The Fantastic Four expecting it to be utterly crap, sub-average boogers, and such. I was...hesitant. I was actually pleasantly surprised, and walked away from the movie feeling quite happy that some things were done well, even if a lot of the movie didn't quite live up to its potential. I think there is a problem among the Marvel Comics movies, that they're writing for the sequel - because at this point it's a given. The first movie is more like the set-up, and hopefully the sequel proves to actually follow through on some things. It's similar to a problem held by actual comic books - writing for the trade paperback collection, so that the monthly books end up as pages after pages of slow-moving decompressed sequences, wherein you might end up with half the actual content is, say, Batman walking down the stairs to the Batcave. Gawd.
I think in the end that I prefer the Spider-Man movies more, and the X-Men movies have the advantage of some really solid performances (Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellan, obviously) mixed in with some bad ones (James Marsden, yawn, Halle Berry -- please kill me). Fantastic Four suffered a similar fate, in that I walked away absolutely in love with two of the characters/actors, and wishing a painful stabby death to the three other principals. Why?
1. Chris Evans as Johnny Storm, the Human Torch. Okay, so part of it - an infinitesemal fragment - of it was that Evans is utterly hot, but that's part of it, because Johnny's got to be a heartthrob. However, he practically revelled in the role, and they wrote Johnny as if he actually really enjoyed having super-powers and flying and catching on fire. He was funny, horny, enjoyed what he was doing, hyperactive and impulsive, and worked well as a prankster with a developing friendship with Ben Grimm - he's insensitive but loveable. Evans delivered a solid performance, and went all out for it, going so far as the spend fifteen minutes of the film wearing nothing but a pink ski-bunny jacket around his waist after an accident with his powers while skiing.
2. Michael Chiklis as Ben Grimm, the Thing. The Thing is really the only member of the Four that should be a whiny bitch. Really, he's the one that turns into a giant lump of clay, stony-faced and weighing too much to actually make it onto a barstool. He is isolated from humanity, his ex-girlfriend, his family -- and Chiklis pulls all of this off, as well as the essential paradox of the character, that he's a grumpy sarcastic bastard rather than a depressive. He and Johnny develop a strong interaction that propels most of the film, the "sitcom sequences" when the team is actually just a dysfunctional family with super-powers. The make-up designs for the Thing were good, in that they veered away from the comic book but worked with Chiklis's body and facial structure to create an interesting visual.
And the bad?
3. Ioan Gruffud as Reed Richards, Mister Fantastic. He looked uncomfortable in his role, had very little chemistry with his love interest, Susan, and came across as snivelling all the time. He's supposed to be the smartest guy in any room, ever. The CGI for his shape-shifting powers looked awkward, although they did manage to demonstrate the slightly disgusting nature of reshaping one's organs and body. Boring city. They could have replaced him with a robot.
4. Jessica Alba as Susan Storm, the Invisible Woman. Weak actress. Yes, emphatically, the Invisible Woman must be a hottie. Yes. She and her brother Johnny are supposed to be incredibly hot. But you know what? There are plenty of actresses out there with looks and acting chops, you know? And I didn't really like how they made her so ineffectual as a character, when the comic's Susan has developed into a real strong character; I would have preferred they make her more clearly the corporate businesswoman that she's supposed to be, concerned with putting a positive spin on their transformations and coining their codenames -- Johnny does that -- to make them celebrities in order to prevent them from being called freaks. Particularly Ben. In the comics, Susan is essentially the head of the "business" side of the Four, the FF Inc. side; while Reed patents gadget and technology after gadget and technology, she actually handles the accounts and keeps them in the black. Alba was wooden on the screen. The romantic scenes with Reed were laughable, and not in a pleasant belly-laugh way. She and Reed whine about being sick, having symptoms rather than powers, and what? No fun? Bitching and complaining about the fact that you can turn invisible whenever you want and generate forcefields? Bah! I will give Alba props for doing some fairly amusing semi-naked scenes to rival Evans's, and I can say that neither men nor women are unequally objectified.
5. Julian McMahon as Victor Von Doom, or theoretically Doctor Doom. They never actually call him that. Which is really too bad, because this movie had the potential to be the Anti-Batman Begins; Johnny & Ben antics, sidled with the goofy villain name Doctor Doom and being ridiculously funny. I like that he's basically an arrogant bastard who's always wanted to show Reed up, that worked fine, but they had to tie him into their origin because - hey - that's the formula for superhero movies now. He's like Lex Luthor's obnoxious cousin. Some fairly generic transformation sequences and powers (oo, electrical blasts and magnetic thingees, like Magneto does, only shittier), a tacked on pseudo-romantic rivalry with Reed over Susan, and they telegraph the transformation with all the metal statues, masks, and such. His name is fucking Von Doom. Have a little fun with it. Geez!
We see the FF start to become celebrities, check. Ben meets the future love of his life, check. I could have done with some reference to Spider-Man, since they all operate out of the same city and the cool thing about Marvel was that they always met up with each other, but whatever. CGI was decent for the most part and by the end of the film the four were working in unison and doing fun things like funnelling water through Reed at Doom. Susan got a nose-bleed from containing a nova-blast with her force-field, a good detail in my mind.
Now, maybe, the sequel might actually be really, really good!