Not quite a top ten, because tastes always change and whatever new story I read that I like instantly becomes one of the best in the world, or something. But a list of ten favourite stories, with the understanding that it's actually impossible for me to count all my favourite instances of short fiction. Rules: only one story per writer, one story per anthology, and it has to be widely published.
1. "People Like That are the Only People Here: Canonical Babbling in Peed Onk," by Lorrie Moore. She's normally known more for her second person stories, but I like this not-quite-third person story from Birds of America. It works with a very carefully balanced ratio of bathos and pathos, and you're never quite sure where you stand with the narration. Additionally, it succeeds in being a hospital story that doesn't make me want to retch.
2. "Light is Like Water," by Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Magic realist, or fantasy depending on your point of view. A pretty loose little story which worked with Marquez's wonderful voice while avoiding the confusion found in some of his longer works, like One Hundred Years of Solitude. I think I like it because it takes a basic conceit - that light is like water - and runs with it. Gorgeous ending. From the Strange Pilgrims collection.
3. "Calling," by Richard Ford. I believe it's in A Multitude of Sins. Introduced me to the retrospective narrator concept, and works it really well; we get a good sense of where the character is now, versus where he was then, and the character's father ran off with a gay opthamologist, which is a great detail. Unfortunately with Ford, after a while you start to be overwhelmed by all his stylistic tics, but this one stands well on its own.
4. "Burn, Baby, Burn," by Poppy Z. Brite. It's a peculiar form of genre fiction, found in an anthology of prose stories inspired by the characters from the Hellboy comics. I've only read a few of Brite's short stories, and would certainly include her story, "The Devil of Delery Street" which has a lot going for it, but for some reason I keep coming back to this story which is fun and amusing and tragic at the same time. The first line: "The girl waits by the side of the road, just past Lolita age but obviously still jailbait."
5. "Mrs. Turner Cutting the Grass," by Carol Shields. From Various Miracles. While quite a lot of Shields bores me - particularly The Stone Diaries, this story is probably one of my all-time favourites, with a roving point of view and some deliciously nasty moments. Starts off with a fairly surface scene and then implodes inside the character of Mrs. Turner, exploring her "wild days" before and all the twists and turns she's gone through.
6. "Lusus Naturae," by Margaret Atwood. From McSweeney's Enchanted Chamber of Astonishing Stories. I'm being a maverick by not selecting something from Good Bones (think "The Female Body") or Wilderness Tips ("Hairball"), but I like this because its more recent Atwood that I still really enjoy. It's her horror story, written from the point of view of the monster, as it were. It has some delightful choices of diction like "dry whiskery sausages" and drips Gothic feel while holding so much of Atwood's wit at the same time.
7. "The Fall River Axe Murders," by Angela Carter. I'll always have a soft spot for Lizzie Borden, but this story is quite brilliant - a stylistic experiment I'd never seen before, taking place in an empty house before the murders actually happen, when everything is just potential and repressed desire. This was my introduction to Carter, who I find myself rather at odds with because it feels like she was writing my stories decades before I was born.
8. "The Wishing Box," by Sylvia Plath. Published in Johnny Panic and the Bible of Dreams. A small, depressive story surrounding a woman's inability to dream and her growing hatred of her husband's ridiculously vivid dreams. If you've heard of Plath you can probably guess how it ends, but there's something haunting about the story and its explorations of lost imagination.
9. "Careful," by Raymond Carver. Available in The Paris Review Book of... Probably one of the most beautiful stories I've ever encountered, with lack of communication between estranged Lloyd and Inez. It's pristine. It's a delight, even as the growing unease is there.
10. "Pastoralia," by George Saunders. Mad, weird satire on theme park culture and the revisionism of prehistory. A contemplation of how deeply we must become our occupations. A man and a woman working in a Natural History museum, where they must act out lives as prehistoric people. The slow breakdown of the living situation.
Next up will be ten favourite poems, or ten favourite movies.